AskPatty Certified Female Friendly Logo
I really really want a 2009 convertible beetle for my first car! Is this car safe? Does it have good MPG? I'm 5'7 with long legs, would that matter and I need to carry my golf clubs with me daily. Would this be a good first car for a 16 year old girl?

Answers from the Automotive Experts

Brandy Schaffels, Editor at, Inc. According to MSN Autos (, the 2009 Beetle was rated at four out of five stars for the NHTSA crash tests for Driver and Passenger front frontal crash test, as well as the NHTSA rollover test. The 2009 Beetle was rated at five stars (out of five) for the front side crash test and three stars for the rear side crash test. IIHS rated the Beetle with a "Good," their highest rating for crashworthiness in every injury measurement. These scores indicate that the Beetle is a safe vehicle. Fuel economy was rated at 20 mpg city and 29 mpg highway. As far as your size, only a detailed test drive will tell you if you will be comfortable in the car. Be sure to bring your golf clubs with you to ensure they will fit in the car along with you. For my first car, I wanted to buy a used Fiat Spyder convertible. I was in love with that car, but my father thought it was a poor choice for a girl's first car. 30 years later, I still disagree. Only the girl and her family can discern what is the best first car for her: it all depends on who is paying for repairs and the condition of the car she is buying. Trust your family's input, your parents will have your best interests in mind.

Georgia Brown, Director of Education at National Independent Automobile Dealers Association (NIADA) First check the cost of insurance for a girl your age for this convertible. If you can afford that, I would go try one out for size. Only you can decide if it's a good fit.

Colleen McGee, Driving Instructor at Americas Driving School Hi Kaeley The gas mileage on VW Beetles is between 20-29 mpg, more on hwy less in the city. People who own Beetles give them good reviews. The passenger side has an acceptable safety rating while the drivers side has a good rating. I don't think your height or long legs would be a problem. That would be a fine car for a 16 year old girl. my sister has owned one for many years.

Contribute to this question:

blog comments powered by Disqus

Related Volkswagen Beetle FAQs

  • Car will not turn over when trying to start. I have been told this could be due to ... Read More

  • I have a 2005 VW Beetle Convertible. It has an annoying 3-beep warning when I get to ... Read More

  • I have a 2004 Volkswagen Beetle convertible. I need a driver's side door ... Read More

  • What does the indicator that is a circle with a line through it mean? Read More
  • This morning when I was leaving work my car would not start. I had to have Security jump ... Read More
  • My indicator lamp light came on ..what does this mean is it serious Read More
  • This only started today but when i drive my four way flashers keep flashing and my doors ... Read More
  • The car has 127,000 miles--Took it in for a tune up. They did spark plugs, fuel filter ... Read More
  • My 2009 Volkswagen Beetle doesn't start! The radio and power go on but makes a clicking ... Read More
  • Heat gauge shows My Volkswagen Beetle is running hot. The mechanic said both fans need to ... Read More

Need Car Advice?

Ask The Experts!

Looking for a New or Used Car?

Search for our Certified Female Friendly® Car Buying Marketplace locations

Help Our Charities